Whiplash wrote: I have no plot no goal to inflict pain so much as I felt you should live who you are. I don’t care about sexual orientation at all, it looked like you did (I very well could be wrong) so after many weeks of still fighting I figured if you felt like making a larger issue out of things at a later date perhaps I would try that to keep the fighting to a minimum. Well that didn’t work very well did it.
No, not well at all.
Two things I can't leave unaddressed:
"...live who you are." suggests that you think you know who someone is by having invaded his banter with friends and cherry picked what fit your agenda (there was never a breath out of you about the
thousands of Star Chamber references to the
hundreds of people in Dogfight we respect, like, admire...only the tiny percentage that were negative and that served your pre-existing purpose.) and it suggests that you think you know something about a person's life by passing casual judgment on a photograph. And
this is the point that needs stressing: looking at a photo and deciding that a person might be gay or bi or straight is no different than looking at a person and deciding that she might have "a drop of black blood". As if sexual orientation or racial makeup has the slightest bearing on who someone is insofar as it's your business to know. Subtle forms of bigotry are still bigotry and this isn't all that subtle. You were going to "use" what you guessed my sexuality to be against me if you deemed it necessary. There's no reason to assume that someone with that thinking wouldn't also seek to use a person's race or religion against them "to keep the fighting to a minimum." I'm not piling on here, I'm genuinely hoping you'll see this for what it is and consider some alternative thinking in future.
That you've taken so much action in service to, "...I felt you should live who you are." implies some sort of right to live who people are for them. You've said you have a gay member in your Dogfight squad. Does he/she have family or friends who don't know she/he is gay? Is that anyone else's concern? Is it your position that your squad mate needs you to out him/her?
A lot of attention is paid to who thinks what about how we choose to play this game. Do you dump your bomb or carry it? Do you drill up the middle or fly wide or high? Head-on sniper or dogfighter? Words like "disgraceful" can be bandied about or blown off without much harm either way. But when judgments of what constitutes suitable behavior extend to personal lives and privacy it's no longer a game, it's serious and insidious and demands to be challenged.